Tuesday, December 26, 2006

Where Eagles Dare


Jamezwp brings up a good point from Febuary 05 when we discussed aquiring Jeff Garcia off of free agency instead of Jake Plummer. After a few rocky seasons in Cleveland & Detroit Jeff Garcia is making a great fit in a Philadelphia Eagles team who many were writing off after the injusry to star QB Donovan McNabb.

5 Comments:

Blogger quest4facts said...

That is a good point because at the time Plummer had no experience in the west coast offense and Garcia was fluent in the lingo. Hindsight is 20/20 but the only concern that I have is I think Plummer is a more winning QB than Garcia. They are both average QB's who make their fair share of mistakes and throw picks.

The silver lining is that coach Shannahan had the guts to go after the future franchise player in Jay Cutler. Either Garcia or Plummer (obviously) would still play second fiddle to Jay Cutler so I say we did good with getting Plummer and almost making him a Champ.

9:18 AM  
Blogger Jamezwp said...

I say we would of done better with Garcia than we did with Plummer. I said it 2 years ago, and I say it now. It's a moot point anyway, and really isn't worth discussing. I am excited about Cutler, he is obviously a better QB than Jake ever was.
I disagee that Plummer is a "more winning QB". He was a loser in Arizona, and when he came here, our good system provided him with many wins. He can only win when the running game is pounding out 150+ per. Garcia has the ability to put the team on his own back and win, as he is currently demonstrating.
Damn, I just look back and think if Garcia were here the last 2 seasons, we would have been a much better team. Cutler wouldn't of been put in prematurely, and Denver would be in a better situation right now.

3:52 PM  
Blogger RED said...

Also think about this. AFC Championship last season Vs. The Steelers and Jeff Garcia playing QB. We could have our 3rd title in Denver as well if Garcia was the QB instead of Plummer.

4:53 PM  
Blogger ATL falcon girl said...

Just wanted to say hi guys I am here I know yall are like where have you been its been ages. Well as usual my life is a neverending cycle of drama and plus I am ready to fire the coach for my time.

9:22 AM  
Anonymous Lance said...

I think we should acquire Garcia although he is a fag he can guide us if Cutler gets knocked like he did against the 49ers Plummer seemed uninterested in saving our season obviously his time is up here wish him well thank him for winning three out of every four regular season games and thanks for the 1 playoff win go Cutler

10:16 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home