Plummer or Cutler?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cba55/cba5553c7fac08d5162c7fed95e542c0ecd2c8ef" alt=""
I know a lot of Denver fans are calling for Plummers head on a stick because the lack of offensive productivity, however, the Broncos are atop the AFC West with a 5-1 record and are sitting as the #2 seed in the AFC if the playoffs were to start today. What are your thoughts on whether the Broncos should stick with Plummer or go to the unproven rookie Cutler.